Advisory Panel

Please click on a profile below to expand:

Tracy Alexander, Forensic scientist specialising in cold-case reviews

Tracy Alexander

Tracy graduated from King’s College London with an MSc in forensic science and sits on the council of the British Academy of Forensic Sciences.

She has worked in forensic science for over 25 years, spending 17 years within the Directorate of Forensic Services at New Scotland Yard as Crime Scene Manager for the Homicide Command and later as Head of Forensic Intelligence.

Thereafter she worked for several years as a cold case investigation specialist at LGC Forensics.

Tracy continues to teach post-graduate forensic science at Kings College and University College London and is undertaking a PhD in complex DNA interpretation at the UCL Jill Dando Centre for the Forensic Sciences.

Her current role is Director of Forensic Services for the City of London Police.

Jill Battley, former senior Detective, New Scotland Yard

Jill Battley

Jill Battley, MA (Cantab), MBA, CFE, CIRM

Jill was Head of Intelligence at New Scotland Yard for the Serious Crime Directorate and has a broad range of experience as a Senior Investigating Officer and in Crisis Management. Her extensive UK and international investigative expertise includes working overseas in a high-risk environment and she is on the United Nations list of International Experts.

She now works for a range of private and public sector clients to prevent and reduce the impact of crime using a broad range of innovative technology systems.

John Devitt, Senior Policing Oversight Specialist & Investigator

John Devitt

John is a former Scotland Yard Detective and Senior Investigator for the Office of the Police Ombudsman for Northern Ireland. John has extensive major crime investigation knowledge and experience. He has over his long career undertaken some of the most challenging, complex and sensitive investigations nationally and internationally.

John is currently an Independent Professional Investigator and Security Consultant. He has been a Member if the Institute of Professional Investigators since 1992.

Andrew Duffin, Investigator

Andrew Duffin

Andrew has over thirty years’ of experience as an Investigator and featured as an industry spokesman on the BBC Radio 4 programme, The Report. He sits as a Committee Member on the British Standards Institute panel responsible for BS102000 ‘The Provision of Investigative Services’.

He is a Fellow of the Institute of Professional Investigators, a Qualified International Investigator, a Member of the World Association of Detectives; the World Association of Professional Investigators and an Accredited Counter Fraud Specialist.

Andrew is also the Data Protection Officer for Inside Justice and a Member of the International Association of Privacy Professionals.

Lorna Hackett, Barrister

Lorna Hackett

Lorna Hackett (formerly Elliott) is a barrister called in 2003, who has conducted numerous high-profile cases in recent years. She has extensive litigation and appeals experience, particularly in the areas of judicial review and human rights.

Lorna has considerable expertise advising in cases of a sensitive nature and in which there is potential for media interest.

Mark Harries QC, Barrister

Mark Harries

Mark Harries QC is a criminal defence barrister at Carmelite Chambers in London. He was called to the Bar in 1995 and appointed Queen’s Counsel in 2019. He has a wealth of experience defending allegations of murder and manslaughter together with considerable expertise in white collar fraud work. He also defends in professional discipline and regulatory cases and in Courts Martial in the UK and abroad.

Mark is a leading advocacy trainer at Lincoln’s Inn, Chair of the Carmelite Pupillage Committee and a mentor for the Social Mobility Foundation, a charity which provides guidance and support for low-income students with university and career aspirations.

Dr Steve Heaton

Steve Heaton

Steve’s interest in miscarriages of justice can be traced back to BBC Rough Justice in the 1980’s which covered the case of Margaret Livesey who was convicted of murdering her teenage son Alan. The murder happened in the village of Bamber Bridge on the outskirts of Preston where Steve lived during his childhood.

A career in the Civil Service and Political Lobbying in the Rural Sector ended in 2009 when Steve commenced studying for a Ph.D at the University of East Anglia. Building on two earlier degrees (Psychology and Law) he was awarded the Ph.D in 2014. The key research for the thesis was undertaken by examining case files at the Criminal Cases Review Commission at various stages in 2010 and 2011.

Steve’s experience of the inner workings of CCRC, coupled with his knowledge of casework acquired running the Innocence Project at UEA for 7 years, will enable him to provide invaluable guidance and insight on the case work at Inside Justice.

John Kennedy, Head of Digital Forensics

John Kennedy

John Kennedy was a Consultant Forensic Scientist at the Government owned Forensic Science Service (FSS) before becoming Head of Digital Forensics at Key Forensic Services. John is currently the Managing Director of the Forensic Science Bureau Limited where he specialises in the Forensic Analysis and Interpretation of CCTV imagery. He is also the Training Programme Manager for LEVA ( with responsibility for organising training in Forensic Video Analysis for UK and International Police CCTV Officers. John has helped pioneer a number of forensic video processes involving complex comparison and Reverse Projection work and these are now used by Law Enforcement Agencies all over the world.

He has attended LEVA training in Forensic Video Analysis at the FBI Academy at Quantico and at the University of Indianapolis. He has attended as a guest speaker at the National FBI Academy in Quantico, at the University of Indianapolis Forensic Video Analysis Training Lab and at Law Enforcement training and development conferences in Washington State, Washington DC, San Francisco, Boston, Chicago and San Diego. He is a member of the International Association of Chiefs of Police (IACP) and has sat on their Advisory Panel for Digital Evidence for Public Safety. He is a professional member of the Chartered Society of Forensic Sciences.

Matthew McDonagh, Criminal & Regulatory Barrister

Matthew McDonagh

Matthew McDonagh is a criminal and regulatory barrister who was called to the Bar in 1994.

He has years of experience in appearing before criminal courts including the Court of Appeal, Criminal Division and regulatory and professional disciplinary tribunals and the Administrative Court.

He practises from Outer Temple Chambers and sits as a Recorder of the Crown Court.

Eric McGraw MBE, Former Editor of Inside Time Newspaper

Eric McGraw

Eric McGraw is a former Director of New Bridge (1986 - 2002) and founder of Inside Time.

He previously worked as a consultant for the United Nations Development Programme and is the author of several books and publications on the subject of ‘world population growth’ and its impact on poverty, development and the environment.

Eric was recently invested with the MBE for services to the Rehabilitation of Prisoners in England and Wales.

Jo Millington, Forensic Scientist specialising in blood pattern analysis

Jo Millington

Jo is an experienced scientist renowned for presenting a robust and balanced overview of forensic scientific evidence to the court, in the UK and internationally.

Jo has worked hard to build a solid foundation of expertise and a reputation in the robust evaluation of complex findings and in communicating this in a straightforward manner.

She is committed to knowledge transfer, maintaining a number of collaborative links with academic institutions.

Jo currently holds the position of Director/Forensic Scientist at Millington Hingley Ltd. She previously worked within the Specialist Forensic Services division of the Metropolitan Police Service and as a Forensic Specialist with the Forensic Science Service (London).

Jo has both UK and international expertise in Blood Pattern Analysis (BPA) interpretation and training and has 20 years’ experience in forensic investigation including hundreds of major and critical incidents.

Dr Ann Priston OBE, Forensic scientist specialising in fibre work

Ann Priston

Dr Priston is former President of the Forensic Science Society. During her early career she worked on DNA synthesis in the Nobel-Prize-winning team at King’s College London.

She joined the Metropolitan Police Forensic Science Laboratory in 1970 and became a case-reporting officer dealing with most biological evidence until eventually specialising in the examination of textile fibres. For 10 years she concentrated on cases involving PIRA activity on the mainland and was recently given a (rarely awarded to civilians) Commissioner’s Commendation for her contribution to the investigation into terrorism on the Greek mainland over the last 30 years.

She has worked on cases from N. Ireland, Gibraltar, Malta, Antigua, Athens, Cyprus, Turkey, Norway, Bermuda, Barbados, Italy, Germany and Canada. She has delivered training presentations to the Forensic Science Service, the Metropolitan Police Crime Academy and the University of Sussex.

She is also a visiting lecturer at King’s College London teaching graduates studying for a Masters degree in Forensic Science and a tutor for the Inner Temple Advocacy Master Class. For many years Dr Priston designed and ran training days for Judges of the London Crown Courts, the Court of Appeal and the High Court.

Dr Priston holds the Freedom of the City of London and in March 1998 was invested with the OBE in 2004.

Sam Robins, Intelligence Manager

Sam Robins

Sam Robins is an ex-police Intelligence Manager and Analyst. She has twenty years’ operational experience within law enforcement. The majority of her service was with Surrey and Sussex Police. In that time she gained and developed extensive knowledge and skills in overt and covert investigations, tactical and strategic operations, intelligence and analysis.

Sam was the Chair for the Major Incident Analysts Working Group, a sub group of the Homicide Working Group. During her time as Chair she assisted in developing national guidance and continuous professional development for Analysts working in this specialist field. Having spent over 10 years working exclusively on Major Crime, Sam was privileged to work on many high-profile and sensitive enquiries such as the successful conviction of Levi Bellfield for the abduction and murder of schoolgirl Amanda Dowler and the murder of British Nationals in the French Alps.

Sam is now an independent advisor and specialist who continues to work with law enforcement and private sector clients.

His Honour John Samuels QC

His Honour John Samuels QC

His Honour John Samuels QC is a retired Circuit Judge, having sat either part-time or full-time for 27 years in the Crown Court (including 16 years as a deputy High Court judge prior to his full-time appointment). He was Chairman of the Criminal Committee of the Council of Circuit Judges and sat in the Central Criminal Court and other London Crown Courts. He was a judicial member of the Parole Board for his maximum tenure of 10 years.

In retirement he has continued to be involved with criminal justice issues: he is President of Prisoners Education Trust, has chaired the Criminal Justice Alliance; is a Vice President of Unlock, AMIMB and Tempus Novo; is a Patron of Prisoners Advice Service; and has served as a trustee of the Centre for Crime and Justice Studies and the Howard League for Penal Reform. He has been a visiting Professor at Nottingham Law School since 2012.

Louise Shorter, Journalist specialising in criminal justice issues

Louise Shorter

Louise Shorter chairs Inside Justice Advisory Panel meetings. She was a Producer of BBC’s long-running investigative TV series Rough Justice for 10 years before setting up this Inside Justice.

Louise is on the Board of Directors of Inside Time and was a consultant to the Guardian’s Justice on Trial website when it was launched.

Louise continues to be involved in media projects, most recently Raw Television’s Conviction series for BBC.

Dr Denise Syndercombe-Court, Forensic Scientist specialising in DNA analysis

Denise Syndercombe-Court

Denise is a highly respected scientist, academic, statistician and published author with over twenty years’ experience in laboratory research and evidential examination. She is a court-going accredited expert witness, giving evidence in court on many occasions over the last fifteen years. Her appointment as a Reader in Forensic Genetics at King’s College London has allowed her to teach forensic genetics to undergraduate and post-graduate students and supervise those undertaking research for their doctorates.

She leads an ISO17025 Ministry-of-Justice-accredited laboratory that specialises in human relationships. She is a blood pattern expert and statistician. She is a member of several professional societies (Biochemical Society, British Academy of Forensic Science, Faculty of Forensic and Legal Medicine, Forensic Science Society, Institute of Biological and Medical Sciences, International Society of Forensic Genetics, Royal Statistical Society and the Society of Biology), represents the UK on the European DNA profiling group and is the International Society of Forensic Genetics representative to the Forensic Regulator.

Since 2002 her group has been the UK partner, with other European Forensic Institutes, undertaking research in the forensic arena: STADNAP, SNPforID and EuroforGen, presenting her research and attending relevant International meetings.